Consumer Groups Urge Changes to Bill C-22 to Protect Data Privacy
OpenMedia, along with 25 other organizations and experts, is urging Prime Minister Mark Carney to take action before the Senate concludes its review of Bill C-22, Canada’s lawful access legislation. The coalition is advocating for the removal of provisions that would allow the government to mandate companies to retain records on all users, as well as addressing potential loopholes that could undermine encrypted messaging.
In a letter dated November 19, signed by groups including Amnesty International and the Internet Society, the organizations express concern that the bill contradicts the Prime Minister's vision of a sovereign Canada that values the protection of its citizens. They argue that legislation allowing for backdoor access to encrypted services is incompatible with European laws and could hinder Canada's economic integration with Europe.
The letter highlights statements from privacy advocates, including Matt Hatfield, Executive Director of OpenMedia, who emphasized that no democracy should require service providers to maintain sensitive data on millions of citizens who are not suspected of any crime. This sentiment echoes concerns raised by tech executives during earlier discussions about the bill.
Bill C-22 was introduced in March after the government separated lawful access measures from a previous border bill. In May, Apple’s privacy executive Erik Neuenschwander warned that creating a backdoor for law enforcement could also expose users to hackers. Google Canada’s Jeanette Patell echoed these concerns, stating that secret orders could compel companies to develop interception capabilities, even though police already have tools for specific investigations.
The House of Commons passed the bill on June 18, following amendments that reduced the maximum data retention period from one year to six months and limited compelled decryption to data that providers can unlock. However, the new letter argues that providers could still be compelled to capture messages before encryption or after they are decrypted on the recipient’s device.
Tech Giants Raise Encryption Concerns
During a Senate hearing on November 16, representatives from major tech companies expressed their inability to comply with the bill as it stands while still providing secure, end-to-end encrypted services. Meta’s Robyn Greene stated that the company could not meet the requirements of the bill without compromising security. Signal’s Udbhav Tiwari went further, indicating that his company would withdraw from the Canadian market rather than weaken security measures for users.
As the Senate continues to review Bill C-22, the implications for data privacy and encryption remain a critical topic of discussion. Apple and Google are scheduled to return to Parliament on November 23 to provide further testimony on the matter, with privacy advocates closely monitoring the developments.
Final Assessment
The signatories of the letter warn that the bill could jeopardize Canada’s status under EU privacy regulations, which currently allow for the transfer of personal data from Europe to Canada without additional safeguards. As the Senate's national security committee deliberates on the bill, the question remains whether Ottawa will heed the calls to eliminate the blanket data retention powers and focus on targeted orders linked to specific investigations.
The ongoing debate surrounding Bill C-22 underscores the tension between national security interests and the protection of individual privacy rights. As stakeholders from various sectors weigh in, the outcome of this legislative process will have significant implications for the future of data privacy in Canada.




