Settlement Reached in Major Medical Data Breach Affecting 13.3 Million
The New York attorney general has reached a settlement concerning a medical data breach that affected over 13.3 million individuals due to significant security lapses. Perry Johnson & Associates and four related companies have agreed to pay $300,000 and to implement extensive security reforms following the breach that exposed personal and medical information. They could face an additional $9.7 million in penalties if they do not comply with the settlement terms.
Attorney General Letitia James announced the agreement on November 6, alongside her counterparts from Connecticut, Michigan, and New Jersey. Approximately 4.2 million of those affected were residents of New York.
The investigation revealed a series of security failures, including remote access without multifactor authentication, the use of nearly identical passwords shared via email, sensitive files lacking file-level encryption, and security software that detected malicious activity but failed to alert security personnel.
The breach was discovered when the attackers contacted the companies on May 2, 2023, demanding payment. The compromised database contained records of over 13.3 million individuals, with the number of affected patients previously reported as approximately 8.95 million. The settlement documents now indicate a larger figure, and the total number could be higher, as the attorney general found that attackers accessed files in shared network storage containing personal and health information, which the companies did not review to identify additional affected individuals.
Delayed Notifications and Legal Violations
Notifications to affected individuals were also delayed. Perry Johnson & Associates began informing clients about the stolen database files in July 2023, while its clients notified affected individuals between October 31, 2023, and February 8, 2024. The New York attorney general determined that the companies violated state requirements to disclose a breach promptly and without unreasonable delay.
Final Brief
Although the settlement is valued at up to $10 million, the companies are required to pay $300,000 in penalties to the states, with New York receiving $100,000 from this initial payment. The remaining $9.7 million is suspended and could become payable depending on compliance. It is important to note that these payments are to the states and do not constitute compensation for the affected patients.
The exposed information poses a risk for criminal exploitation. Research indicates that stolen identity packages can sell for as little as 95 cents each on the dark web. The settlement mandates extensive security changes for the involved companies, reflecting the severity of the breach and the number of records compromised.




